Lyric Soprano Denise Battle & Pianist Oksana Lutsyshyn
Prince of Peace Lutheran Church, Virginia Beach
June 30, 2013
Review by John Campbell

A locally grown and developed recitalist, Denise Nicole Battle, is a beautiful young woman with a beautiful, powerful voice. A native of Portsmouth, Virginia and a recent graduate of Norfolk State University, Ms. Battle has been singing since age four in church and then in choirs: the NSU Concert Choir, Spartan Chorale - directed by Dr. Carl W. Haywood (2006-2008) and the I. Sherman Greene Chorale - directed by Mr. Terry Butler (2009-2011). Realizing that she wanted to perform art song, Ms. Battle has studied for the last three years with Karen Hoy, a local expert in the genre.

We first heard Ms. Battle three years ago singing solo art songs at a Karen Hoy Studio recital with several other singers. Ms. Battle impressed us then as a singer to watch and this recital was a confirmation of her developing abilities.

Her opening song, by G.F. Handel from his opera Giulio Cesare, was V'adoro pupille (I adore you, eyes) with a glorious, big sound that expanded with clarity and ever more power. It was an emotional epiphany for this listener. Amarille, mia bella by Giulio Caccini (1551-1618), written for the Medici family, helped develop the genera of opera when the Renaissance was giving way to the early Baroque style. Love is the subject of this song that flows with winning beauty. Each repetition of the beloved's name displays a new ornamentation. It is one of the great, early art songs.

The last in the Italian language set, Vittoria, mio core! (Victorious, my heart) by Giacomo Carissimi (1605-1674) is a song about moving beyond the fire of passion and its cruel torments. The voice that opened-up fully in the final phrase was stunning.

The German set began with Dein Blaues Auge (Your blue eyes) and continued with Der tod, das ist die ku'hle nacht (Death is the cool night). Both settings were by Johannes Brahms (1833-1897). Wearing an apricot, floor-length, spangled dress with a shaped bodice and a full skirt that fell with pleats, Ms. Battle gently moved her hands as if she were a potter shaping the sound to perfection. There is a sense of mystery in singing of death as a cool night contrasted by the energy of the line about sultry day. At the end the singer longs for rest.

Next we heard the lullaby Venetianisches Wiegenlied by Austrian composer Joseph Marx (1882-1964). The bell-like tones in the piano remind us how essential Ms. Lutsyshyn is in shaping the experience of each song. The journey of a lifetime is captured in this three-minute song. The set concluded with Brahms' Von ewiger Liebe (Of Eternal Love); a grand title, for sure, but Brahms delivers and so did our performers. A young man is seeing his beloved home in the dark of night - no birdsong, no lights. They chat on with abandon until he offers her a way out if she suffers disgrace from being with him, setting off a vocal tour-de-force as she refuses: “Iron and steel are firm but can be recast but our love will last forever!” The vocal strength builds line-by-line. By the end it is an amazing display of beautiful power by both artists.

The aria Ach, ich fuhl's (I feel it), from Mozart's The Magic Flute ended the first half. Pamina laments a budding love that seems to have faded. As a test of his obedience, Tamino is under orders not to speak. Misinterpreting his silence as rejection, she is so despondent that she wishes for death.

After intermission Ms. Battle's vocal teacher, Karen Hoy, spoke of the years of preparation and the need for performance opportunities for young singers to hone their skills. Ms. Hoy has organized the Cantabile Series which will sponsor its first recital and master class this fall, offering a platform for developing talent on stage.

After a French tune played by Ms. Lutsyshyn, Ms. Battle, wearing a blue gown, reappeared and asked the audience to applaud only at the end of each set, rather than after each song. Three songs by Gabriel Fauré (1845-1924), sung in French, followed. Notre amour (Our love) is the French way of conveying the same sentiment of the last Brahms song. Our love is something light, enchanting, sacred, infinite and eternal, all swiftly told. The quiet intensity and word painting of En Sourdine (Muted) speaks also of love set in natural surroundings. The desire to continue this sweet moment is poignant. The third selection was Après un rève (After a dream). Asleep the lover is spellbound by happiness until he awakes, only to go back to sleep to return to the splendor of love that he found only there. In Ms. Battle's voice the words have such meaning.

The songs of local composer Adolphus Hailstork (b.1941) are not as nationally known as his choral and orchestral works. We are thankful that local singers bring them to our attention. From his set of Three Simple Songs we heard two songs. Not in Vain (text Emily Dickinson) is a clear, unsentimental statement of a useful life of caring for those problems that come our way. Daffodils (text William Wordsworth) is a meditation on the joys of life focused on a single experience of thousands of daffodils seen beside a lake. In reverie the poet recalls and writes of the scene and his heart dances once again with rapture.

In the line "You can tell the love of Jesus and say 'He died for all" the high soprano phrase seemed new in Harry T. Burleigh's (1866-1949) Balm in Gilead. The flute-like sound of the voice in "heal the sin-sick soul" was lovely.

Turning to the opera Turandot by Giacomo Puccini (1858-1924) we heard Liu's love for Calaf expressed in Signore, ascolta (Sir, listen!) as her heart breaks because he loves only Turandot. Her last selection was from Gian Carlo Menotti's (1911-2007) The Old Maid and the Thief. The song Steal Me, Sweet Thief is sung by an old maid who rues her forty years of spinsterhood. The song is filled with longing. A drifter is taken in by her kindhearted maid and the lady of the house desires that he make a pass at her: “steal my lips before they crumble to dust…” bringing to an end this full recital with such amazing singing and playing.

The fifty listeners were told by Ms. Hoy that Denise Battle had been given a full-tuition scholarship and a paid teaching assistanceship at West Virginia University to pursue her master's degree in vocal performance this fall. We hope she comes often to sing for us at home as she grows in skill and repertory at WVU.

Back to Prince of Peace 9